REAL RESULTS · CA WORKERS COMP

Workers Comp Case Studies: Real California Employers, Real Results

Independent brokerage means we work for you, not for one carrier. These case studies show how California employers across industries have used better broker representation to lower their ex-mod, fix misclassifications, escape the assigned risk pool, and right-size their coverage.

Reviewed by Bollinsure Insurance Services — CA Licensed Broker, License #0D94699
ROOFING · MOD REDUCTION

Roofing Contractor Reduces Ex-Mod from 1.35 to 0.94

A 12-employee Inland Empire roofing contractor cut their experience modification by 30% over three years through claim advocacy and safety program implementation.

From 1.35 to 0.94 in 3 Years
RESTAURANT · CARRIER SHOPPING

5-Location Restaurant Group Saves $44K at Renewal

Seven years with the same carrier with no competitive re-quote. A market submission to 7 carriers revealed $44,000 in annual overpayment.

28% Lower Premium at Renewal
CONSTRUCTION · CLASSIFICATION AUDIT

GC Recovers $22K from Class Code Correction

Eighteen employees coded under the wrong class code for years. A mid-term audit and code correction produced an $11,000 refund and $22,000 in annual savings.

$22K Refund from Code Correction
HEALTHCARE · ASSIGNED RISK EXIT

Healthcare Staffing Agency Exits the Assigned Risk Pool

A 1.52 mod had trapped a 40-person home health agency in California's assigned risk pool. An 18-month claim and safety program returned them to the voluntary market.

From Assigned Risk to Preferred Market
PROPERTY MGMT · SAFETY PROGRAM

Property Manager Hits Zero Claims for 3 Straight Years

A systematic IIPP and subcontractor COI management program eliminated claims entirely — bringing the mod to 0.74 and triggering an additional carrier schedule credit.

Zero Claims for 3 Consecutive Years
LANDSCAPING · MOD TURNAROUND

Landscaping Company Cuts Ex-Mod from 1.38 to 1.04 in Two Renewals

A Sacramento-area landscaping company reversed a strain-claim streak with a return-to-work program, claims review, and a unit-stat correction — and watched the premium follow the mod down.

From 1.38 to 1.04 in Two Renewals
TRUCKING · REMARKETING

15-Truck Fleet Turns a 28% Renewal Increase Into 7%

After one severity claim spooked the incumbent carrier, remarketing with telematics safety data and cleaned-up driver files landed a competitive market at a single-digit increase.

28% Increase Cut to 7%
MANUFACTURING · AUDIT DISPUTE

Machine Shop Cuts a $22,000 Audit Bill by 72% on Review

Clerical staff reclassified to the shop rate at audit over commingled duties. Rebuilt payroll-separation records won the dispute — and the separation discipline now survives every audit.

$22,000 Bill Cut to $6,100

What These Case Studies Demonstrate

Market Access

An independent broker submits your risk to every carrier willing to quote it. A captive or single-carrier agent can only offer what their carrier prices. The restaurant group case shows a $44,000 difference between a loyal incumbent and an open market — for identical risk.

Classification Accuracy

California workers comp premium is calculated by class code and payroll. Errors in classification — employees coded under the wrong code, payroll allocated incorrectly — create overcharges that persist silently until someone audits them. The GC case recovered $11,000 in a single mid-term audit.

Claim Advocacy

Open claims inflate your experience modification through reserve values. Brokers who engage actively with claim examiners, defense counsel, and carrier SIU units can accelerate claim closure and reduce reserve bloat. The roofing and healthcare cases both turned on reserve corrections that accelerated mod improvement by 12–18 months.

Proactive Mod Management

The experience modification is calculated from three years of claim data. Every dollar of claims from three years ago affects today’s premium. Employers who implement safety programs, RTW protocols, and documented IIPPs create compound improvement — the property management company’s 0.74 mod was built over 36 months of zero-claim years.

Sources & References

Get Started

Ready for a workers comp indication?

Takes about 4 minutes. No commitment. We’ll review your class codes, ex-mod, and current pricing — and show you what the full California market has to offer.

Get a pricing indication →

Or call us directly: 562-COVWELL · reviews@bollinsure.com